Is
Leopold Bloom a Jewish Freemason?
Eishiro Ito
Eishiro
Ito, during his talk on Freemasonry in Ulysses, cited Bernard
Benstock
as quoting one Fritz Senn to the effect that Bloom was a master Mason,
thereby initiating the following dialogue: "Senn: Who said that?
Ito: You." (A check with the source established that, according to
Benstock,
Fritz had speculated that Bloom might have been a "lapsed
Mason.")
Ito, I should add, also taught us, or anyway me, new things about
Joyce's
uses of Freemasonry and distributed a handout that I actually intend--
and this is by no means always the case-- to keep as a valuable
reference
on the subject. He also, getting in the spirit of things, led us
in a sing-along of a Masonic anthem.--John Gordon, Conneticut
College
--James Joyce Quarterly, 37.3/4 (Spring/Summer
2000), 325.
|
This essay
brings focus into James Joyce's
Ulysses, especially into Leopold
Bloom's Jewish identity and his relationship with Freemasonry,
referring
to the problems of the Jews and Freemasonry in early twentieth-century
Ireland.
Keywords:
James
Joyce's Ulysses, Freemasonry, Jews of Ireland,
|
The full
version is available in the Journal of Policy Studies, Vol.3,
No.2 (Policy Studies
Association, Iwate Prefectural University, December 2001), 1-15.
Copyright 2001 Eishiro Ito
|
Introduction
Leopold Bloom, a Jewish-Irish
hero
of the Odyssean novel, Ulysses, is rumored to be a
Freemason.
Early in the novel, Nosey Flynn has said of Bloom, "He's in the craft"
(U 8.960), while he passes the Freemason Headquarters in
Molesworth
Street (U 8.1151). Later, the man called "the citizen"
refers
to Bloom, "What's that bloody freemason doing ... prowling up and down
outside?" (U 12.300-1). In several parts of the Circe
episode,
Bloom gives a sign of Freemasonry. Even Molly says twice that her
husband was a Freemason (U 18.382 & 1227). Although
some
critics like Patrick W. Conner explain that Bloom is no longer a Mason
simply because he converted to Catholicism in order to marry Molly, he
still has a touch of Masonry.
Ira B. Nadel notes in Joyce
and
the Jews that ever since the eighteenth century, the idea of Jews
and Freemasons
forming a secret conspiracy planning to take over the world provided
anti-Semites
with much material: most dangerously, Jews were disguised as Christians
and infiltrating the priesthood(210). Freemason lodges had in
fact
long admitted Jews. So it seems to me that James Joyce
strategically
put Freemasonic signs throughout Ulysses, establishing the
thematic
importance of Masonic concepts in the novel with the protagonist having
a Jewish background.
Freemasonry was established in
Ireland in June 1725.1 The number
of Irish Freemasons
increased from about 28,000 in 1920 to 43,000 in 1925; in Dublin alone
there were 59 Freemason lodges in 1920, and in 1925 there were 70.2
The biography
John Stanislaus Joyce by John Wyse Jackson and Peter
Costello notes that a Republican raid on the Molesworth Street
headquarters
led to intense embarrassment for certain of the Dublin burgesses when a
substantial number of Catholic Freemasons was revealed(383). The
Irish Freemasons were a more successfully oathbound secret society than
the Irish Revolutionary Brotherhood had ever been, according to Jackson
and Costello(384). In 1896 the Irish Catholic Church
accused
French Freemasons of Devil worship.
This essay focuses on Bloom's
Jewish identity and his relationship with Freemasonry, referring to the
problems of the Jews and Freemasonry in early twentieth-century Ireland.
I. Freemasonic References
Joyce asked Frank Budgen in his
letter dated Nov. 6, 1921 to send him "any little handbook of Brit.
Freemasonry."
3
Later Budgen informed Ulrich Schneider that he was not sure whether he
sent such a book, but was inclined to think he did not.4
It suggests that Joyce already had some sources, because several
allusions
to Freemasonry were added to the text before that request. But it
is very difficult to identify what sources Joyce used for the Masonic
references.
One plausible reference is Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th ed.
(1910-11),
especially its entry, "FREEMASONRY." Another source, particularly
for the Circe episode, would be A Ritual and Illustrations of
Freemasonry(London,
1837) as Schneider says(304). Judging from the fact that
Joyce
inserted them in different stages after the Little Review
series,
Joyce used several books including a British or Irish Freemasonic
source.
As Joyce told Frank Budgen, his
complete man in literature is Ulysses, i.e. Odysseus, because " Ulysses
is son to Laertes, but he is father to Telemachus, husband to Penelope,
lover to Calypso, companion in arms of Greek warriors around Troy and
King
of Ithaca" and Joyce saw him "from all sides, and therefore he is
all-round
in the sense of your sculptor's figure. But he is a complete man
as well--a good man. At any rate, that is what I intend that he
shall
be"(17-18).5
Leopold Bloom, a Jewish-Irish
hero of the Odyssean novel, Ulysses, is rumored to be a
Freemason.
When Nosey Flynn says of Bloom, "He's in the craft" (U 8.960),
he
is showing off his knowledge of Freemasonry there. This passage
contains
many implications to Freemasonry:
08.958.
Nosey Flynn made swift passes in the air with juggling fingers. He
08.959. winked.
08.960. --He's
in the craft, he said.
08.961. --Do you
tell me so? Davy Byrne said.
08.962. --Very much
so, Nosey Flynn said. Ancient free and accepted order. He's
08.963. an
excellent
brother. Light, life and love, by God. They give him a leg up. I
08.964. was told
that by a - well, I won't say who.
08.965. --Is that
a fact?
08.966. --O, it's
a
fine order, Nosey Flynn said. They stick to you when you're
08.967. down. I
know
a fellow was trying to get into it. But they're as close as damn
08.968. it.
By God they did right to keep the women out of it.
08.969.
Davy Byrne smiledyawnednodded all in one:
08.970.
--Iiiiiichaaaaaaach!
08.971. --There
was one woman, Nosey Flynn said, hid herself in a clock to find
08.972. out
what
they do be doing. But be damned but they smelt her out and swore
08.973. her in
on the spot a master mason. That was one of the saint Legers of
08.974. Doneraile.
(Italics mine)
The "craft," in speculative Masonry,
signifies
the whole body of Freemasons in allusion of the heritage of ancient
guild
of craftsmen. Nosey Flynn's comment, "Ancient free and accepted
order,"
suggests "Scotch Rite, Ancient and Accepted," which was originally
instituted
in Scotland and is, next to the York rite, perhaps the most extensively
diffused throughout the Masonic world in many countries like England,
Scotland,
Ireland, France, and the United States, according to Albert Mackey's A
Lexicon of Freemasonry. "They give him a leg up" is based on
the popular suspicion as Don Gifford notes in "Ulysses"
Annotated:
"Masons gave excessive preference to members of their order, even to
the
point of handing out money" and "the order is committed to help and
support
its members and families in time of disease and personal crisis."
"They're as close as damn it" is also based on another suspicion
'reflecting
not only the exclusive nature of the order but also the assumption that
the order involved a profound and conspiratorial "secret"' and 'the
order
was open to any man at least twenty-one years of age and in body "a
perfect
youth"'(Gifford). In addition, Flynn even refers to Elizabeth
Aldworth
(d.1773): "The celebrated 'Lady Freemason,' the Hon. Mrs. Aldworth (nee
Miss St Leger, daughter of Lord Doneraile), witnessed a Masonic meeting
and was initiated in Ireland c certainly not later than 1713, when the
venturesome lady was twenty"(EB11). But since Flynn
refuses
to unveil the source of his knowledge, the reader has no reason to
believe
it more than a rumor.
The Doneraile Court,
Doneraile,
County Cork6
In the Little Review
version
published in January 1919, this passage was already almost as it is in
the text now as well as the Falkiner passage below in the
February-March,
1919 issue(V.9-49;V.10-11,61).
Bloom watches Sir Frederick
Falkiner,
going into the Freemason Hall (headquarters) in 17-18 Molesworth Street
(U 8.1151).
The Freemason Hall in
Molesworth
Street7
Falkiner was the chief judicial
officer
of Dublin 1904(1831-1908), the notoriously anti-Semitic judge, who
makes
several appearances in the novel, most notably in the Circe episode
where
he stands in judgment of Bloom and sentences him to death (U
15.1158-80).8
At Barney Kiernan's, Joe Hynes calls Bloom "the prudent member"(U
12.211). According to Mackey's Lexicon, "Prudence" is one of the
four cardinal virtues, the practice of which is inculcated upon the
Entered
Apprentice. Later in the Cyclops episode, the man called "the
citizen"
refers to Bloom, "What's that bloody freemason doing ... prowling up
and
down outside?" (U 12.300-1). Near the end of the novel
Molly
remembers twice in her late night monologue that her husband was a
Freemason
(U 18.382 & 1227). These rumors show that Bloom still
has a touch of Masonry, although he converted to Catholicism in order
to
marry Molly. As Leonard Albert says in his article, "Ulysses,
Cannibals and Freemasons" that "Tradition says that there are no
ex-Masons;
once a Mason, always a Mason. Secrecy, of course, requires
life-commitment
to the order" (272).
Bloom was almost arrested in 1893
or 1894 for attempting to sell tickets for "The Royal and Privileged
Hungarian
Lottery" and was apparently rescued by members of his Masonic Lodge:
1.
08.184.
Windy night that was I went to fetch her there was that lodge meeting
08.185. on about
those
lottery tickets after Goodwin's concert in the supperroom or
08.186. oakroom of
the Mansion house. He and I behind.
2.
12.770.
Then he starts all confused mucking it up about mortgagor under the
12.771. act like
the lord chancellor giving it out on the bench and for the benefit of
12.772. the wife
and that a trust is created but on the other hand that Dignam owed
12.773. Bridgeman
the money and if now the wife or the widow contested the
12.774. mortgagee's
right till he near had the head of me addled with his mortgagor
12.775. under the
act. He was bloody safe he wasn't run in himself under the act
12.776. that time
as a rogue and vagabond only he had a friend in court. Selling
12.777. bazaar
tickets
or what do you call it royal Hungarian privileged lottery.
12.778. True as
you're
there. O, commend me to an israelite! Royal and privileged
12.779. Hungarian
robbery.
(Italics mine)
3.
18.1224. Helys and
Mr Cuffes and Drimmies either hes going to be run into prison
18.1225. over his
old lottery tickets that was to be all our salvations or he goes and
18.1226. gives
impudence
well have him coming home with the sack soon out of the
18.1227. Freeman
too like the rest on account of those Sinner Fein or the freemasons
(Italics mine)
The factual source for this detail
appears
in the Illustrated Irish Weekly Independent and Nation, 16 June
1904, p.4, col.7, as Gifford notes. At the stage of the Rosenbach
Manuscript, Passage 1 had no connection with Freemasonry: "Windy night
that was I went to fetch her of the Goodwin's concert in the supperroom
of the Mansion house. He and I behind" (Rosenbach MS8-5).
In
the Little Review version (V.9-31-32, January 1919), "there was
that lodge meeting on about those lottery ticket after" was inserted.
In the Circe episode, where
Bloom's
most hidden thoughts emerge in his consciousness, the Masonic motifs
are
taken up many times:
15.449: BLOOM
15.450: (squire
of
dames, in dinner jacket with wateredsilk facings, blue masonic
15.451: badge
in his buttonhole, black bow and mother-of-pearl studs, a prismatic
15.452: champagne
glass tilted in his hand) Ladies and gentlemen, I give you
15.453: Ireland,
home and beauty.
- - - - -
-
- - - - -
-
- - - - -
15.499: (Richie
Goulding,
three ladies' hats pinned on his head, appears
15.500: weighted
to one side by the black legal bag of Collis and Ward on
15.501: which a
skull and crossbones are painted in white limewash. He
15.502: opens it
and shows it full of polonies, kippered herrings, Findon
15.503: haddies and
tightpacked
pills.)
(Italics mine)
Gifford explains that "limewash" is
associated
with Freemasonry: in the Scottish rites (which were observed in
modified
form by Irish Freemasons) a skull and crossbones, symbolic of mortality
and death, were used in the Chamber of Reflection as a part of the
preliminary
ceremonies of initiation. Joyce seems to have put "limewash" and
"a skull and crossbones" into the text before he inserted "blue Masonic
badge" in the Typescript (Buffalo V.B.13.h: JJA15.172).
"Blue" is
the color used for the decorations of the first three degrees of
Masonry
(Entered Apprentice, Fellowcraft, and Master Mason) according to
Mackey's
Lexicon.
Bloom gives one of the Freemason's
"signs of distress," a signal that makes "brothers immediately known to
their brethren" so that they can claim assistance and protection:
15.757. BLOOM
15.758. (scared,
hats
himself, steps back, then, plucking at his heart and lifting his
15.759. right
forearm
on the square,
he gives the sign and dueguard of fellowcraft)
15.760. No, no, worshipful
master, light of love. Mistaken identity. The Lyons mail.
15.761. Lesurques
and Dubosc. You remember the Childs fratricide case. We
15.762. medical
men.
By striking him dead with a hatchet. I am wrongfully
15.763. accused.
Better one guilty escape than ninetynine wrongfully condemned.
15.764. MARTHA
15.765. (sobbing
behind
her veil) Breach of promise. My real name is Peggy
15.766. Griffin.
He wrote to me that he was miserable. I'll tell my brother, the
15.767. Bective
rugger
fullback, on you, heartless flirt.
15.768. BLOOM
15.769. (behind
his
hand) She's drunk. The woman is inebriated. (he murmurs
15.770. vaguely
the pass of Ephraim) Shitbroleeth.
(Italics mine)
As for "Due Guard,"
Mackey explains: "We are by this ceremony strongly reminded of the time
and manner of taking out solemn vows of duty, and hence are duly
guarded
against any violation of our sacred promises as initiated members of a
great moral and social institution." "Fellowcraft" is the second
degree of the first three degrees of Freemasonry; "The members are
classified
in numerous degrees, of which the first three are 'Entered Apprentice,'
'Fellow Craft' and 'Master Mason,' each class of which, after
initiation,
can only be attained after passing a prescribed ordeal or examination,
as a test of proficiency, corresponding to the 'essays' of the
operative
period" (EB11). The phrase "worshipful master, light of
love"
suggests that Bloom has reached the highest preferment within his
lodge.
The "light" of Masonry is pure, as emanating from the source of all
purity
and perfection, and the word "Worshipful" is the title given to a
symbolic
lodge and to its presiding officer, the Master(Mackey). Those
Masonic
phrases were inserted later in the Page Proofs (Buffalo V.C.1, Texas; JJA26.87).
Bloom continues to act a Freemason
master:
15.2720. BLOOM
15.2721. (In Svengali's
fur overcoat, with folded arms and Napoleonic forelock,
15.2722. frowns in
ventriloquial exorcism with piercing eagle glance towards the
15.2723. door. Then
rigid with left foot advanced he makes a swift pass with
15.2724. impelling
fingers and
gives the sign of past master, drawing his right arm
15.2725. downwards
from his left shoulder.) Go, go, go, I conjure you, whoever you
15.2726.
are!
(Italics mine)
Bloom
performs as a "Past Master," one
holding an honorary degree conferred on the Worshipful Master at his
installation
into office; in this degree the necessary instructions are conferred
respecting
the various ceremonies of the order, such as installations,
processions,
the laying of corner stones(Mackey). He tries to combine the
power
of Svengali, the demonic Jewish musician of George Du Maurier's novel
Trilby and the majestic power of Napoleon. Here he performs two
signs
of a Past Master to allude to the penalty of a Past Master, which
covers
all the former penalties.9 The
phrase "gives the sign
of past master ... shoulder" was added in the Page Proofs(Buffalo
V.C.1,
Texas; JJA26.219) as well as "In Svengali's fur overcoat" and
"in
ventriloquial exorcism."
In the masochistic hallucinations
of Bloom and Madam Bella Cohen (Witch Circe), Bloom still keeps his
Masonic
identity. He is transformed into one of Bello (the masculine
Bella)'s
whores and lies before the witch:
15.2850. BLOOM
15.2851. (her eyes upturned in the sign of admiration, closing, yaps) Truffles!
15.2852. (With
a piercing epileptic cry she sinks on all fours, grunting,
15.2853.
snuffling,
rooting at his feet: then lies, shamming dead, with eyes
15.2854. shut
tight, trembling eyelids, bowed upon the ground in the attitude
15.2855. of
most excellent master.)
(Italics mine.)
15.2856. BELLO
15.2857. (with bobbed
hair, purple gills, fit moustache rings round his shaven
15.2858. mouth, in
mountaineer's puttees, green silverbuttoned coat, sport skirt and
15.2859. alpine hat
with moorcock's feather, his hands stuck deep in his breeches
15.2860. pockets,
places his heel on her neck and grinds it in) Footstool! Feel my
15.2861. entire
weight.
Bow, bondslave, before the throne of your despot's glorious
15.2862. heels so
glistening in their proud erectness.
15.2863. BLOOM
15.2864. (enthralled, bleats) I promise never to disobey. (Italics mine)
The phrase
"bowed upon ... most excellent
master" was added in the Page Proof (Buffalo V.C.1, Texas;
JJA26.226),
while "I promise never to disobey" had been earlier in the text.
Since Bloom has assumed a Masonic "attitude," his phrase "I promise
never
to disobey" could be taken as part of the apprentice Mason's oath of
initiation.
The act of bowing upon the ground is the sign of admiration, is found
in
Masonic ritual in the ceremony of a candidate's acceptance as a most
excellent
master.10
After Stephen smashes the
brothel's
chandelier with his ashplant, Bloom negotiates with Bella Cohen about
paying
for the damage, making a Masonic sign:
15.4241. STEPHEN
15.4242. Nothung!
15.4243. (He
lifts his ashplant high with both hands and smashes the
15.4244.
chandelier.
Time's livid final flame leaps and, in the following
15.4245.
darkness,
ruin of all space, shattered glass and toppling masonry.)
- - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - -
15.4296.
BLOOM
15.4297. O, I know.
Bulldog on the premises. But he's a Trinity student. Patrons of
15.4298. your
establishment.
Gentlemen that pay the rent. (he makes a masonic
15.4299. sign)
Know what I mean? Nephew of the vicechancellor. You don't want a
15.4300.
scandal.
(Italics mine)
Bloom tells
a lie that Stephen is a student
of Trinity College, the famous English Protestant College established
by
Elizabeth I in 1591. Gifford notes that Bloom suggests
Freemasonry
has an influential connection with the Protestant Anglo-Irish
Establishment.
Bloom's Masonic sign was earlier directed in the Rosenbach MS 15-73.
As the Circe episode closes,
Stephen
is lying unconscious in the street outside the brothel. He has
been
knocked down by the two English soldiers, who imagine he has insulted
the
name of King Edward VII, ex-grand master of the Grand Lodge of England.11
Bloom, the father seeking a son to replace his own dead son, Rudy,
bends
over Stephen, whom he has been protecting throughout the episode.
Stephen murmurs Yeats's "Who Goes with Fergus" from Countess
Cathleen.
Looking down on the prostrate boy, Bloom feels obscurely some sense of
his trans-substantial paternity, and a religious mood possesses him
vaguely:
15.4948. BLOOM
15.4949. (communes
with the night) Face reminds me of his poor mother. In the
15.4950. shady
wood.
The deep white breast. Ferguson, I think I caught. A girl.
15.4951. Some girl.
Best thing could happen him. (he murmurs) ..swear that I will
15.4952. always
hail, ever conceal, never reveal, any part or parts, art or arts
..(he
15.4953. murmurs)
..in the rough sands of the sea ..a cabletow's length from the
15.4954. shore....
where the tide ebbs.... and flows .....
15.4955. (Silent,
thoughtful, alert he stands on guard, his fingers at his lips in
15.4956. the
attitude
of secret master. Against the dark wall a figure appears
15.4957. slowly,
a fairy boy of eleven, a changeling, kidnapped, dressed in an
15.4958. Eton suit
with glass shoes and a little bronze helmet, holding a book
15.4959. in his
hand.
He reads from right to left inaudibly, smiling, kissing
15.4960. the page.)
15.4961. BLOOM
15.4962. (wonderstruck, calls inaudibly) Rudy!
15.4963. RUDY
15.4964. (gazes, unseeing,
into Bloom's eyes and goes on reading, kissing, smiling.
15.4965. He has a
delicate mauve face. On his suit he has diamond and ruby
15.4966. buttons.
In his free left hand he holds a slim ivory cane with a violet
15.4967. bowknot.
A
white lambkin peeps out of his waistcoat pocket.) (Italics mine)
This
passage contains the most significant
allusions to Masonic ceremonies and symbols. Bloom's murmurings,
as Schneider notes, are part of the oath sworn by the candidate when he
is initiated as an Entered Apprentice (309) : his oath signifies his
vision
of Stephen's initiation as a Mason, though Stephen does not repeat the
oath, and might misunderstand it just as Bloom misunderstands his words
from Yeats's poem. Bloom's oath, "[I] swear that I will always
hail,
ever conceal, never reveal, any part or parts, art or arts," is not
only
the oath of secrecy but also the oath of initiation: he performs the
"secret
master"(Schineider 310). The "secret master" is the fourth degree
in the Ancient and Accepted Scotch rite, and the first of the Eleven
Ineffable
Degrees, which "represents Solomon coming to the temple to elect seven
experts" (Schneider 310).12
In the National Library
of Ireland MS , we cannot find Rudy (Circe MS Folio 27), but we can
find him in the
Rosenbach MS15-85. The above two Masonic phrases were inserted in
the Page Proofs (Baffalo V.C.1, Texas; JJA26.336) probably to
intensify
Bloom's paternity. "A white lambkin" was already in the Rosenbach
MS, which can be another Masonic image; "The Lamb has, in all ages,
been
deemed an emblem of innocence. He, therefore, who wears the
lamb-skin
as a badge of Masonry, is, thereby continually reminded of that purity
of life and conduct which is essentially necessary to his gaining
admission
into the Celestial Lodge above, where the Supreme Architect of the
Universe
presides."13
As Leonard Albert says, in the
stage-directions in U15.4955-56, Joyce makes it quite clear
that
Bloom knows the secret sign of the secret master-Mason, as well as the
obligation. And it is in this religious moment that he sees a
vision
of his dead son Rudy over Stephen. Freemasonry is a symbol of
fraternal,
and paternal love. As Daniel Schwartz notes in Reading
Joyce's
"Ulysses," Bloom's Masonic behavior becomes important in a chapter
dramatizing Bloom's repressed and unspoken fantasies and hallucinations
since Masons cannot speak about Masonry except to fellow Masons (223).
II. Jews & Freemasonry
Ira B. Nadel
notes in Joyce and the Jews that ever since the eighteenth
century,
anti-Semites believed that Jews and Freemasons formed a secret
conspiracy
planning a world takeover: "Jews, with their esoteric mysticism,
Talmud,
and Kabbalah, were, of course, the leaders" and "the providential
ministers
and Grand Masters of occultism" (Nadel 210-11).
Although the Jews were a strong
element in Masonry from the beginning, they acquired a preponderating
influence
in the organization from about the middle of the eighteenth
century.
This Jewish element was Partheistic. Thus the Jews all over
Europe
became a powerful, wealthy and anti-Christian element in the councils
of
Masonry.14 Masonic
symbolism is peculiarly
Jewish in character, and the terms used in the lodges are borrowed from
the Old Testament.
By the late nineteenth century,
Pope Leo XIII's anti-Semitism provided new momentum in joining Jews and
Masons in a conspiracy theory. "With books and pamphlets
appearing
with such titles as French Masonry--Synagogues of Satan, and
Freemasonry,
Jewish Sect, or The Jewish-Masonic Peril, it is no surprise
to read of the opposition of Catholicism to Ernesto Nathan's
campaign"(Nadel
211). Ernesto Nathan was the first Israelite and Freemason Mayor
of Rome (1907-13). Every appointment he made during his term of
office
was given to a Mason. The Italian government became
Masonic.
The country was poor, degraded, seething with discontent. It had
almost reached the very verge of bankruptcy. Such was the
condition
of Italy when Mussolini and the Facisti came on the scene, "saved the
Italian
nation," and "saved the Church" by suppressing Masonry as the main
cause
of all the trouble in Italy, both to Church and State.15
Nadel notes that The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, the
notorious
forgery of the Tsarist secret police, embodied the international
conspiracy
theory through its detailed discussion about Jewish-Masonic
co-operation(211).
Thus, people suspected that the Masons, or instruments of the Jews, had
caused all revolutions of the past few centuries.
Then what did all of this mean
to Joyce? The connection of Bloom with the Freemasons is constant
throughout the novel and anti-Semitic connotations are implied as
well.
Both may derive from the attacks on Ernesto Nathan and his election
campaign
by the Church around the time when Joyce stayed in Rome between 1906-7,
as Nadel argues(212). After leaving Rome, Joyce must have
followed
Nathan's election campaign from Trieste: cf.U 5.203-5: "I hear
the
voice of Nathan...." Joyce's brother Stanislaus noted in his
diary
on 10 November 1907, the very day the Roman municipal election was
held,
that "Joyce told me that he was going to expand his story 'Ulysses'
into
a short book."16 Until that
time, 'Ulysses' was
to be a story of the Jewish Dubliner, Alfred H. Hunter. Bloom's
speech
as the Lord Mayor of Dublin in the Circe episode (U 15.1354-)
overlaps
that of Nathan because both are Jewish Freemasons.
III. Irish Freemasonry
Freemasonry
was an important sphere of the Jews in contact with the Gentiles, and
eight
out of some forty householders in a community belonged to Lodge 206 of
the Irish Constitution in Dublin in 1770-1, one rising to the high
office
of Prince Mason, as Louis Hyman states in Jews of Ireland (52).
Freemasonry,
with all its Hebraic and Templar evocativeness, bridged many social
gaps
for the Jews of Dublin. Excluded from the freedom of the city and
the guilds, and from the benefits of naturalization, the Irish Jew "was
bound to be taken by the notion of belonging to a non-sectarian
organization
which forged a bond of brotherhood between him and men of different
creed
and assured him of the knowledge that the right hand of good-fellowship
would be held out to him by his brethren of the 'mystic tie,' whatever
was his creed"(Hyman 59). Jews became prominent in the craft very
soon after the so-called revival in 1717, but it was not until 1770
that
Jewish names can be found in Masonic record in Ireland(Hyman 59).
As Marilyn Reizbaum says in James
Joyce's Judaic Other, Deasy's reference to "she [Ireland] never let
them [the Jews] in" (U 2.442) should perhaps be read as a
metaphor
for Jewish exclusion from Irish society (itself a persecutory act) (38).17
This was historically true: in 1871 the Jewish population in all of
Ireland
was 258, and in 1881, 453, mostly of English and German
extraction.
But by the year 1901, the estimate was 3,771, most of them (2,200)
residing
in Dublin, and in 1904, the estimate was probably nearly 4,800.18
The sudden influx at the turn of the century resulted from a wave of
immigration,
primarily from Russia, where Jewish persecution had become acute.
Until then Ireland had not let Jews in, and, with their coming in
greater
numbers, people began to take such attitudes toward Jews as were
prevalent
on the Continent, as Reizbaum notes(38).
On January 12, 1904, a boycott
against the Jews of Limerick was incited by Father John Creagh, who in
a sermon condemned the Jews as usurers and invoked the myth of ritual
murder--the
blood libel. The myth is alluded in Ulysses several
times:
U
6.770-72: Bloom thinks of the superstition that Jews kill Christian
children
in order to use their blood to make matzoth, the ritual unleavened
bread
eaten on Passover ;U 17.810-28: Stephen sings the ballad of
Harry
Hughes, in which a Jewish girl cuts off the head of a Christian boy.
Father John Creagh began to attack
the
Jews in Limerick, January 1904, focusing on the Jews as usurers, and as
a result the Jewish businesses were boycotted there for two
years.
His attack was probably influenced by anti-Semitism during the Dreyfus
Affair while he traveled to France. The loss of livelihood forced
some 75 percent of the Jewish residents in the Limerick Jewish
community
to leave, but the community reestablished itself during World War I
after
the hateful priest was finally forced out.
Arthur Griffith supported the
Limerick
"pogrom," publicizing his anti-Semitism in his articles on the Boer
Wars,
in which he aligned the Jews with the "Imperialist English" (the United
Irishman, July 15, 1899).19
Griffith also insisted
that "the Three Evil Influences of the century were the Pirate, the
Freemason
and the Jew" (the United Irishman, September 23, 1899).20
Griffith is employed in Ulysses essentially as a symbol of one
branch
of Irish nationalism. As Dominic Manganiello notes in Joyce's
Politics, just as "the citizen" could not tolerate Bloom's
freemasonry,
Griffith could not have done so either(173). So when Molly tells
us that her husband would be "those Sinner Fein or Freemasons," there
is
an implicit irony in the statement and Joyce underlines Bloom's secret
activity.
As Reizbaum notes, the Masonic
Order and Judaism have been historically linked as, for example, secret
societies that promote anti-Christian feelings (152 9n). To
suspect
Bloom of Freemasonry is to metonymically identify him as Jewish,
despite
the fact that others quite remote from such associations are spied
entering
the place; as we have seen, Bloom sees the anti-Semitic Frederick
Falkiner
entering the Freemason Hall (U 8.1151).
Toni L. Kamins insists that the
Jewish communities of Ireland have never officially taken sides in the
conflict between Ireland and England, but in practice Jews have been
sympathetic
to the Irish nationalist cause.21
During the 1916
Easter Rising, a number of Jewish homes in Dublin sheltered the rebels,
and Robert Briscoe, Dublin's first Jewish mayor(1956-57; 1961-62), was
a member of the Irish Republican Army(Kamins 120).
Conclusion
It is well-known
to Masons and Catholics alike that, while Catholics can become Masons,
no good Catholics would. That is, although the Masons permit
Protestants,
Jews, and Catholics to join their fraternity--indeed any believer in
the
"Great Architect of the Universe" may be accepted into the
membership--the
Catholic Church does not sanction Masonic activities, and would require
any convert to dissolve his ties with the fraternity.22
Such ties would be necessary for the Jews like Bloom who live in
Ireland,
feeling somewhat alienated from the Irish society.
If we believe tradition, there
are no ex-Masons; once a Mason, always a Mason, so Bloom is still a
Mason
by Masonic law. He might simply stop practicing the craft, that
is,
he stops attending their meetings and functions.
In the Circe episode Bloom and
Stephen are conscious that Stephen is now twenty-two years old(U
15.3712-21). Freemasonic order was "open to any man at least
twenty-one
years of age and in body a perfect youth." As a mythical father
and
(imaginary) Master, Bloom seems to initiate Stephen, his mythical son
to
Freemasonry in the episode, as we have seen. For Bloom's mythical
paternity, Freemasonry is an important element as well as for his
Jewishness.
We cannot definitively identify
Bloom as a Freemason, but we can presume that Joyce, who knew how the
Jews
of Ireland lived around 1904, satirically added a touch of Freemasonry
to Bloom's character.
Albert,
Leonard.
"Ulysses, Cannibals and Freemasons." A.D., vol.2,
no.3
(Autumn 1951),
265-83.
Anonymous. The
Freemason's Companion. Cincinnati: John D. Caldwell, 1883.
Benstock,
Bernard.
"Leopold Bloom and the Mason Connection." James Joyce
Quarterly,
vol.15.
no.3 (Spring 1978), 259-62.
Budgen,
Frank. James
Joyce and the Making of "Ulysses" and Other Writings.
Oxford: Oxford
University Press, 1989.
Conner, Patrick
W.
"Bloom, the Masons and the Benstock Connection." James
Joyce Quarterly,
vo.17,
no.2 (Winter 1980), 217-20.
Coyle, Eugene, The
Rev.
P.P.. Freemasonry in Ireland. Dublin: Seamus
O'Doherty,
1928.
Ellmann, Richard. James
Joyce (new & revised ed.). Oxford: Oxford University
Press,
1982.
Encyclopaedia
Britannica.
11th ed. 29 vols(or EB11). Cambridge, Eng.: The
University
Press,
1910-11.
Gifford, Don with
Robert
J. Seidman.
"Ulysses" Annotated. revised ed. Berkeley:
University
of California Press, 1988.
Huhner, Leon.
"The
Jews of Ireland: An Historical Sketch." Transactions of
the
Jewish
Historical Society of England, 5 (1902-5), 226-42.
Hyman, Louis.
The
Jews of Ireland from Earliest Times to the Year 1910.
Shannon:
Irish
University
Press, 1972.
Jackson, John Wyse
and
Peter Costello.
John Stanislaus Joyce: The Voluminous
Life and
Genius of James Joyce's Father. London: Fourth Estate, 1997.
Joyce, James. Gen.
ed.
Groden, Michael.
The James Joyce Archive(or JJA), 63 vols.
New
York
& London: Garland Publishing, 1978.
--------. Letters
of James Joyce, vol.I. Ed. Gilbert, Stuart. New York:
The
Viking
Press,
1957.
--------. Ulysses:
A Facsimile of the Manuscript I-III (or Rosenbach MS).
London:
Faber
and
Faber in association with The Philip H.A.S.W. Rosenbach
Foundation,
Philadelphia,
1975.
--------. Ulysses.
The Little Review, vols. IV-VII (March 1918-Sep./Dec. 1920)
--------. Ulysses.
London: The Bodley Head, 1986.
Kamins, Toni
L. The
Complete Jewish Guide to Britain and Ireland. New York:
St.
Martin's Griffin,
2001.
Keogh,
Dermot. Jews
in Twentieth-Century Ireland: Refugees, Anti-Semitism and
the
Holocaust.
Cork:
Cork University Press, 1998.
Mackey, Albert G. A
Lexicon of Freemasonry (or Lexicon). London: Charles
Griffin
and
Company.
Ltd., 1883.
Manganiello,
Dominic. Joyce's
Politics. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1980.
Nadel, Ira B.
Joyce
and the Jews. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 1989.
Reizbaum, Marilyn. James
Joyce's Judaic Other. Stanford: Stanford University
Press,
1999.
Schneider,
Ulrich.
"Freemasonic Signs and Passwords in the Circe Episode."
James Joyce
Quarterly, vol.5, no.4 (Summer 1968), 303-11.
Schwarz, Daniel R. Reading
Joyce's "Ulysses." London: Macmillan Press, 1987.
Stewart, K.J.
The
Freemason's Manual. Philadelphia: E.H. Butler & Co., 1851.
|
From: dryfoo@MIT.EDU Date: 2002.11.01 03:55:09 Asia/Tokyo To: acro-ito@iwate-pu.ac.jp Subject: Some notes on Masonry Read your article about Bloom and the Masons. A few small corrections: In your abstract, you refer to Bloom acting like "a Freemason master". This is an ambiguous phrase and doesn't mean exactly either of the two things it could refer to: either (1) a "Master Mason" -- one who has received all three degrees in a "craft lodge" or "blue lodge": Entered Apprentice (1st), Fellowcraft(2nd), and Master Mason (3rd degree), or (2) a Mason who has been elected to serve as Master (presiding officer) of his lodge. One refers to the first as a "master mason" and to the second as a "master of a lodge" "lodge master" or "worshipful master". I see from reading further on that you are familiar with both of these, the Master Mason and Lodge Master. So you can see that your usage "a Freemason master" could refer to either, as is in fact never used at all. Next, "Ancient Free and Accepted" does not imply Scottish Rite (not "Scotch Rite"). Nearly every grand lodge and their constituent lodges in the world refer to themselves as either "Free and Accepted" or "Ancient Free and Accepted". The exact significance of "Free" as in "Freemason" is disputed historically, but nearly all agree that it refers to the mediaeval craft stone masons who were not bound by civil regulations to live and work in one town or city, but were "free" to travel and find their livelihood during the great age of the gothic cathedrals. "Accepted" refers to the practice of initiating men of standing into the craft as honorary members, which many believe is the root, or part of the root of modern speculative freemasonry (as opposed to the operative trade of stone-cutters, brick-layers, etc.) These men were "accepted" or made part of the "acception" -- were members despite not being oprative stone workers. "Ancient" reflects a quarrel early in the days of modern speculative Masonry, when (1717) four London lodges organized themselves into a "grand lodge" for the purpose of arranging a proper ceremonial and feast to celebrate St. John's Day -- their patron saint. This new grand lodge soon began to assert authority over all Masons and lodges in and around London. Other old lodges who disagreed on this plan styled themselves as "ancient" or "antient" and referred to their rivals as "moderns" who were introducing an unacceptable innovation into Masonry. The split was reconciled in England in 1813, but evidence of it remains in bodies (such as the Irish Grand Lodge and many of those in the USA) who refer to themselves as "Ancient Free and Accepted Masons" or "A.F.& A.M. Finally, Scottish Rite masonry was not founded in Scotland, but most likely in France, among Scottish exiles. I hope these short notes will be of interest. I enjoyed your paper and was pleased to learn about the references to Masonry in Ulysses, which I am only now in the process of reading. Best wishes +-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ocean
Lodge AF&AM, Saugus, MA (PM)
"...one
sacred band, or society of Friends and Brothers, among
|